Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

[Caluin Graye]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

The cases' I made were all against Drixx. Seeing as he is gone now, the answer to your question now is, "No, I'm just going by what others have posted and quoted."

<snip>

I have to start from scratch with those I feel are scum, I focused too much attention on drixx.

This is a fair answer, and one deserving an unvote. For now, at least. I'm willing to give you some time.

Unvote: coju

And so far NO ONE has asked me any questions (besides Goriany?), when I clearly stated I'd answer the questions you have.

Why do we have to ask you questions? Why can't you simply volunteer whatever information you're willing to share, and leave it at that? If you don't want to role claim, that's fine, I can respect that. By why do we need to go fishing for whatever nuggets of info we can get out of you? Why not simply say - "Here's all that I know, make use of it as you can."

No, I urge you to keep your information to yourself unless it directly leads to us catching scum, or preventing the lynch of a vital townie.

So who else would know the townies better than the mafia...hmmm?

I.... I don't understand the question. Are you insinuating something?

So are you expecting me to take a cyanide pill as well Caluin Graye??

---------------> Tactical move there Drixx! Kinda had you pegged as a townie all along...we'll be talking about this one for awhile :nod:

Well, according to you, it'd be the most tactical thing to do if you were a townie, right?

In all seriousness, no, I don't expect you to self-destruct. I find your response to my gentle note of suspicion in your direction to be far over the top, however. Guilty conscience? Something to hide?

Incidentally, about CG being bussed...

Normally, only the busderiver and killer would know whether or not CG was bussed. Who was your real target N1?

Since it directly concerns me, I'd also now like a real answer to this question that Goryani posed to you yesterday. I understand you gave some hand-waving answer such as "It's a Gorny game!", but I think you're dodging the line of questioning. Why exactly did you come to the bus driver theory?

 

[Kestegs]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

You the mafia.



And Goryani has taken several scum points for that. If there was something noteworthy that you learned you would've told us. Anything that isn't a guilty shouldn't be made public. Scum kill of confirmed town and possible PR's.

Kestegs insistent interrogation of Korial flagged up too.

Your full of it sath. There is no way that asking for that info is scummy. I was never asking him to divulge power rolls. Guess who knows who the townies and Mafia already are? the Mafia. Korial has been at least 90% confirmed, if he can add 1-2 more confirmed town to that list then why not do it? He has already stuck his neck out as a power roll, which means he likely has a limited amount of time left in the game, drixx sacrificed himself to confirm him, lets not waste anymore lives is all I'm saying.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Anyone else find it odd that Feysal's post restriction is the only one that has persisted beyond a day?

 

[Noammr]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

We don't need Korial to roleclaim, nor do we need any further info from him unless he deems it useful. Let's leave it at that, shall we?

We're late in the day with no clear lynch options.
Time for some questions:

@Asrrin & Malevolent - top three choices for todays lynch in your eyes?
@kestegs - what's your read on Malevolent?
@Noodle - who's looking town to you right now?
@Leo - why sooooo serioussssssss? (also, welcome to the game, glad you could join :wave


Preview edit:
@CG - Feyfey's restriction is the only one tied to his role, the others seem to have been caused by someone else as a night action. In short, I really don't see what we can learn from this.

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Your full of it sath. There is no way that asking for that info is scummy. I was never asking him to divulge power rolls. Guess who knows who the townies and Mafia already are? the Mafia. Korial has been at least 90% confirmed, if he can add 1-2 more confirmed town to that list then why not do it? He has already stuck his neck out as a power roll, which means he likely has a limited amount of time left in the game, drixx sacrificed himself to confirm him, lets not waste anymore lives is all I'm saying.

Mafia doesn't know all the townies. Mafia still need to find either the other mafia team or the SK. And don't make Drixx act noble by saying he sacrified himself to confirm Korial. He ragequitted in a manner that isn't fun for anyone.

And I expect Korial to live for some time, at least untill the doc dies. Korial is save target #1.

 

[Sathoris]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Ooh random questions.

@Noammr and Gwaihir: Who do you two think should be lynched?

And what's your take on Ryleh, Noammr?

 

[Noodle]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Noodle - who's looking town to you right now?

Caluin Grey, corax, and korialstrasz seem to me to be most likely town. I don't have any real strong mafia suspicions, I have to say. I like Caluin's observation that Feysal's post restriction is anomolous, although I'm not sure exactly what to make of it. I'll mull this over and try to provide more input as the day progresses.

 

[Kestegs]

Mafia doesn't know all the townies. Mafia still need to find either the other mafia team or the SK. And don't make Drixx act noble by saying he sacrified himself to confirm Korial. He ragequitted in a manner that isn't fun for anyone.

And I expect Korial to live for some time, at least untill the doc dies. Korial is save target #1.

Yes, I agree and was very vocal about not being happy about the manner he quit. But it is now information that we can use, me not liking it doesn't make it less true.

If korial doesn't have any info for us then I'm not going to push it.


On mal: He is playing true to his normal forum behavior (I know him well from the spf) it often appears as if he hasn't read much of the thread and he is making flippant posts. It makes it hard to decide if he is pro or anti town based on those factors for me.

 

[Noammr]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Ooh random questions.

@Noammr and Gwaihir: Who do you two think should be lynched?

And what's your take on Ryleh, Noammr?

Can't say I have a top lynch picked out just yet. Easier to say who I won't have lynched: you, Korial, Feyfey, Gory and the other two Gmen (gwa-??? and gu-??) who's exact name I tend to forget. Also, Leo, because I like her. Uraj can join the group too, if he really wants to.
Barring a re-read (which I was planning but lacked the time for) all others are on the same level of possible scumminess in my eyes.

Ryleh has been in tunnle-vision mode set on 'Drixx' for a while now but his early gameplay didn't bug me as far as I recall, will have to see how he swings now that Drixx is out of the picture.

Gotta rush off, will be back later for a bit.

 

[Goryani]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Gah. I have far less time than normal. Me mum called last night asking help with her taxes. She didn't want to pay an accountant $600 so yay me. I've never seen so many Schedule K's, partner's basis worksheets, and foreign tax credit gobbledygook (<- is in the forum spelling dictionary, lols) in the same tax year. Luckily this will all go away on the 15th (or she will!).

Uraj's post restriction seems particularly brutal. I see votes and agreements but not much else. Whomever said pictures are worth a thousand words didn't know what they were talking about. The post restrictions seem to be getting worse day after day. I hope the trend doesn't continue. Vote count says Uraj voted Noodle and I only see those "votes" pasted onto a pic.

Not another intentional mod-kill :yuck: These games are supposed to be fun and actions like that suck away half the fun of playing.

Today flubbucket has:

• Placed blanket suspicion on the 8 (?) players not voting for zemaj (#727) while saying the idea came from Uraj. I got the feeling Uraj focused on a specific player (Noodle) rather than a blanket suspicion of 1/3 the town.
• Seems eager to let everyone know he took part in lynching a scum (#729)
• Continues fingering multiple players and attributing anyone voting Drixx as part of the mafia even though flubb himself has voted Drixx in the past. 'Look at what I say, not what I do' type of post.
• The Noodle joke was :thumbsup:.
• Said Feysal made good comments despite Feysal not having a post at that time today.

Past day's activities included:

• bringing up a recruiter possibly affecting himself and busdriver affecting CG (492) but has noting serious to say about either
• making it a point to let everyone know Gorny had the vote count wrong and he voted zemaj (645)
• voted Drixx after Drixx suggested it was better to vote Drixx than suffer another no-lynch (607)
• places the suggestion that anything he posts which seems foolish is merely done to get attention since he feels ignored this game. It's like he knows he will say suspicious things and is already preparing the excuse for doing so. (575)
• D1 he avoided voting zemaj because he thought votes were trending toward coju (402)
• flubbucket deliberately avoided answering any question I had regarding flubb's D1 post restriction and whether or not he thought the targets of BA and Sathoris were made by the same faction (365)

Vote: flubbucket

He triggered numerous and varied scum tells but the D1 bandwagoning vote spliting vote of coju (with no reason given! - 264) and eagerness to take credit for having voted zemaj D2 (with no vote D1) stand head and shoulders above the rest.

I'll promise to read the thread again before end of day. I can't promise more than about 15 min doing so. Sorry. Back to K-1's. Not the funnest way to spend a B-day.

 

[RlyehExiled]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Night Zero actions. I doubt mafia would target their own on D0 with an ability that lead to the other person not being able to post the next day.

If there are more than one anti-town faction, which there seems to be going off narration, he could of just got caught in gang-wars cross fire.

Ryleh has been in tunnle-vision mode set on 'Drixx' for a while now but his early gameplay didn't bug me as far as I recall, will have to see how he swings now that Drixx is out of the picture.

Yeah I'll admit to tunneling there, thing is other than corax's lurking and silly vote behavoir day 1. I have nada in the way of cases against anyone else.

Vote: Corax

But other people have also been lurking/refusing to spam when the thread was being choked, hopefully more discussion from more people will surface now.

I'll check back and reread in a few hours when my head is more clear.

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Wow Goryani that is quite a bit of info you have compiled there.

1) I am town

2) I am not mafia

3) I am not the villiage idiot

4) In an effort to facilitate a lynch today, since we won't get one if I try to argue this nonsense, I will help you out.


Unvote: Sathoris

Vote: flubbucket

Now let's lynch me, find out I'm town and get something down you bunch of goobers!!!

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

(I mean get something done)

Spelling is phun

 

[Valhauros]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I think Feysal's restriction is permanent and the other one (Flub > Me > Uraj) may be contagious. If it is, it'll probably be transferred to Gullik next, like he said. In other matters, since the game has been revolving so much around Drixx and his avalanche of dramatic posts, I don't know who I should vote for anymore, so I'll just follow the bigger bandwagon until either the target gets vindicated, or a better target appears.

Vote: Sathoris

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Aaah crap Val!! We need your vote to get something going, otherwise it will be a no lynch day.


6+ hours and counting

 

[Kestegs]

I don't see a sath Lynch happening. The only Lynch I see as even remotely possible is a corax Lynch. Of course I'll be around later.

vote: corax


Why you in such a hurry to get lynched flubb? Got a deadline to meet?

 

[flubbucket1]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

I'm trying to get something accomplished!!! This bunch of hens around here can't seem to do diddley squat. And we're still talking about Drixx!!!!!! GYAAAHH.......

 

[Kestegs]

Your talking about drixx. Stop pushing your own agenda. If you want to help the town pick a viable Lynch target.

 

[RlyehExiled]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

@Flubb: What's the point of self voting? You say you're town and not the VI (Jesters/VIs tend to be unaligned anyway). Yet voting for yourself is a silly move for the town.

Also you're a townie, who's so desperate to get a lynch they are willing to get themselves lynched rather than no lynch? If you are pro-town how is mislynching you better than not lynching?

A WIFOM move to make you appear pro-town but excentric prehaps?

 

[Malevolent]

Re: Witch Hunt: The NCIS Haloween Forum Mafia Thread

Voting for yourself is NEVER a good option, it just makes you look stupid and if you ARE townie like you claim, then why wouild lynching you be a good idea? Sounds like scum to me!

Unvote: Sath
Vote: Flub